Maxxis vs Toyo vs Michelin

The car currently has Maxxis 307 165/70R14 OEM, and after 20,000 Km are showing a fair bit of wear. I am having a difficult time to find many choices in this tire size, therefore I would like to change to a 175/70R14 which offers more options. This change should not affect the speedometer readings to any appreciable extent. I am contemplating the Toyo 350 (which I have had previously on another car) and the Michelin XM2; I will confess that I am a big fan of Toyo tires due to their quality standards and reputation. The Toyos' are also about half the price of the Michelins'. You thoughts and ideas would be appreciated...TIA.